विवेचन सारांश
War Readiness followed by Arjuna's Despondency
The session started with the auspicious lighting of the lamp and Prayers were offered to Pujya Guruji and Sri Paramatma.
We are the blessed ones for having the privilege of reciting and understanding Śrīmadbhagavadgītā. Due to our past good karmas and by the grace of Paramātmā and our Gurus we have began our spiritual journey.
The first chapter is Arjuna-Viṣāda-Yoga - The Yoga of Dejection of Arjuna. This chapter does not begin the teachings. It describes the battlefield of the war of righteousness at Kurukshetra and how Arjuna got deluded on seeing his own kith and kin arrayed to fight against him and refused to fight them. Śrī Bhagavān tells Arjuna to perform (Svadharma) his duty as a warrior (Kshatriya) and wage the war; is also a lesson for all of us to perform our respected duties that we are designated to do.
Duryodhana was also terrified on seeing the mighty Pandava army. Captivated by fear he began to mumble to lift his own spirits.
1.10
aparyāptaṃ(n) tadasmākaṃ(m), balaṃ(m) bhīṣmābhirakṣitam,
paryāptaṃ(n) tvidameteṣāṃ(m), balaṃ(m) bhīmābhirakṣitam. 1.10
Duryodhana soon realised that his blabbering gave way to his fear of losing. To uplift his own, and his armies spirits, he said that under the leadership of the valiant Bhīṣma Pitamaha and Guru Dronācārya, the Kaurava army was adequate and unconquerable.
Herein Duryodhan used two words aparyāptaṃ and paryāptaṃ. He said his army was paryāptaṃ i.e.. adequate enough to take on the Pandavas aparyāptaṃ (inadequate) army. He said so because the Kuarava's army was being guarded by Bhīṣma Pitamaha and Pandava's army was guarded by Bhīmā, and Bhīṣma Pitamaha was far more valiant and experienced than Bhīmā.
Alhough Jaya Lal ji Goenka took the above view of this shloka, Ram Sukh Das ji interpreted this verse differently. In his commentary he wrote that Duryodhana used the word aparyāptaṃ for his own army and paryāptaṃ for the Pandavas army. Although Kauravas army was more bigger than that of the Pandavas, Duryodhana was insecure because he was aware that Bhīṣma Pitamaha was fighting for the Kauravas half heartedly, as both sides were dear to him. On the other hand Bhīmā would protect Pandava's interest only.
ayaneṣu ca sarveṣu, yathābhāgamavasthitāḥ,
bhīṣmamevābhirakṣantu, bhavantaḥ(s) sarva eva hi. 1.11
Duryodhana's anxiety is portrayed in this verse.
tasya sañjanayanharṣaṃ(ṅ), kuruvṛddhaḥ(ph) pitāmahaḥ,
siṃhanādaṃ(v̐) vinadyoccaiḥ(ś), śaṅkhaṃ(n) dadhmau pratāpavān.1.12
Bhīṣma Pitamaha understood Duryodhana’s anxiety, and to cheer him up gave a mighty roar of a lion and blew his conch that thundered and resonated in the battlefield. and signaled the commencement of the war. This now put to rest Duryodhana's fear of and conveyed to him that Bhīṣma Pitamaha was indeed ready to lead the Kaurava army.
In olden days, blowing of the conch in the battlefield signalled the official start of the war.
tataḥ(ś) śaṅkhāśca bheryaśca, paṇavānakagomukhāḥ,
sahasaivābhyahanyanta, sa śabdastumulo'bhavat. 1.13
The king of the Pandavas is Yudhistira and the commander in chief is Drishtadyumna. As per rules of war, when the most revered and powerful Bhishma blew the conch, it should have been reciprocated by the king or the commander in chief of the Pandava army. However, they looked up to Sri Bhagavan as they considered HIM as their leader and expected HIM to reciprocate Bhishma's signal of initiating the war.
Sri Bhagawan had refused to take part in the war but had promised to side with the Pandavas as a charioteer for Arjuna. Knowingly, the Pandavas instead of reciprocating by blowing the conch, look up to HIM. Such is the power of Bhagavan who has HIS own ways of making things happen. Everyone knew the unsaid - that HE was there to guide and lead the Pandavas.
tataḥ(ś) śvetairhayairyukte, mahati syandane sthitau,
mādhavaḥ(ph) pāṇḍavaś caiva, divyau śaṅkhau pradadhmatuḥ. 1.14
Once Śrī Kṛṣņa and Arjuna were walking in the forest. Agni Deva and Varun Deva appeared and requested Kṛṣņa and Arjuna to burn the Khandava Vana, as it was inhabited by ferocious animals which did not let humans to enter the forest. The Devas said that only Kṛṣņa and Arjuna could carry on this task as Takshak Naga, King Indra's friend, also lived in that forest. They explained that if someone else tried to destroy the forest, Indra Deva would come with His army to protect the forest. However, He would not come if Kṛṣņa and Arjuna were His opponents.
Kṛṣņa was not interested to take on this proposal but Arjuna being a kshatriya agreed. Although he understood the complexity of the task but he was confident of winning as Bhagawan was with him. The forest was burnt. Takshak naga went to Indra for help. Indra Dev along with his vast army came and told Kṛṣņa and Arjuna to spare the forest else He would have to fight with them. They disagreed and a huge war started between Arjuna and Indra's army. Arjuna was a little skeptical as he had never fought with the Devatas. However, Kṛṣņa signalled him to go ahead and fight.
After about 3 months of ferocious war the Devatas were defeated. The forest was also burnt to the ground along with all the ferocious animals. Only Takshak Naga escaped. Agni Deva and Varun Deva were pleased and they appeared and asked Kṛṣņa and Arjuna to ask for a boon. Kṛṣņa asked for everlasting friendship with Arjuna, and Arjuna being a warrior asked for divine weapons and chariot. Agni Deva gifted this divine chariot to Arjuna. Mahabharata describes this divine chariot in detail. It was made of gold, had a never ending supply of divine weapons and ran 2 inches above the ground. Varun Deva also gifted a divine conch shell named Devadutta to Arjuna.
All divine things have three aspects:
1. Adibhautik - that which is observed externally - like horses, reigns, chariot, hood, flag, etc.
2. Adidaivik - having unique qualities - like the chariot running on air and not touching the ground.
3. Adhyatmik - like what Lord Ram explained to Vibheeshana during the war against Ravana in the Ramayana.
Mahabharata war lasted 18 days only. Whereas the war between Sri Rama's army and Ravana's army lasted for 84 days, wherein the fight between Rama and Ravana lasted 18 days. In this fight Ravana had a huge chariot armoured from all directions, whereas Rama ji was without any chariot and that too bare feet.
This made Vibheeshana wonder how Shri Ram would fight Ravana as expressed by Tulsidas Ji in Lanka Kand of the Ramayana:
अधिक प्रीति मन भा संदेहा। बंदि चरन कह सहित सनेहा॥1॥
सुनहु सखा कह कृपानिधाना। जेहिं जय होइ सो स्यंदन आना॥2॥
बल बिबेक दम परहित घोरे। छमा कृपा समता रजु जोरे॥3॥
To stress the importance of bravery and patience, the story goes..
In the Mahabharata war, Arjuna committed a mistake which led to the death of Abhimanyu. Susharma was sent by the kauravas to distract and tackle Arjuna.
Śrī Kṛṣņa advised Arjuna to not loose focus on such an inconsequential person. However, Arjuna was incited, and was bent on killing Susharma. This caused him to chase Susharma, long enough for Abhimanyu to be killed in the absence of Arjuna. This incident showcases that shaurya and dhairya are imperative for a successful life.
Wars in ancient times had great strategies. Since visibility was an important factor, there were flags which signified the status of the warrior. These fluttering flags were visible from afar and warriors could decipher the enemy potential and thus be prepared for a face off. The flags were hoisted on a sturdy pole. Further, the front two horses of the chariot are to lead and give direction. The hind two horses are for pulling the chariot forward. It is very easy to distract the horses with food as they are only animals. The enemies would feed the rival army horses thereby distracting them and bringing misery to the warriors. So the hind horses were trained to not fall prey to their senses in warfare and to be steadfast for the welfare of the warrior in the chariot.
दान परसु बुधि सक्ति प्रचंडा। बर बिग्यान कठिन कोदंडा॥4॥
कवच अभेद बिप्र गुर पूजा। एहि सम बिजय उपाय न दूजा॥5॥
जाकें अस रथ होइ दृढ़ सुनहु सखा मतिधीर॥80 क॥
Another chariot, the spiritual chariot was described. This chariot is pulled by 10 horses, 5 Jnanaindriyas and 5 karmaindriyas (dasarath). The reins that draw the chariot is the mind, and the intellect guides the mind to action. The Jivatma is seated on this chariot. The saints ride this chariot.
Whereas the chariot of the ignorant is the reverse. Here the intellect is enslaved by the mind. The indriyas entangle the mind in materialistic pleasures and the slaved intellect gives in.
Thus it was advised that one must remain conscious of the direction one's chariot is moving as it will determine one's progress on the spiritual path.
pāñcajanyaṃ(m) hṛṣīkeśo, devadattaṃ(n) dhanañjayaḥ,
pauṇḍraṃ(n) dadhmau mahāśaṅkhaṃ(m), bhīmakarmā vṛkodaraḥ. 1.15
Here Bhagavan is called Hrishikesh i.e. Master of the senses. Arjuna has been called Dhananjay. When the Rajasuya Yagya was performed, the four brothers went in four directions to acquire wealth. Arjuna alone brought so much wealth from one direction that the three brothers could not bring together, since then he was named Dhananjay. Bhima has Vrikagni in his stomach which never calms down, hence he got the name Vrikodara.
These are the fourteen gems that surfaced from the churning of the ocean (Sagar Manthan):
Kalkut Vish (Poison) – This was the first to emerge in the churning of the ocean, Shiv ji consumed the poison to save the humanity from calamity and destruction. The secret of this gem is that when the mind is churned, the worst thoughts emerge first. We should never allow evils to descend inside the mind. Rather they should be abandoned.
Kamdhenu Ratna - The sage kept this gem with him. Its secret is that when bad thoughts leave the mind, then our mind becomes pure like Kamdhenu.
Uchchaishrava (Horse) Ratna - It is said that this horse used to move according to the speed of the mind. King Bali had kept this gem with him. The secret of this gem is that whenever the mind wanders, it becomes armed with evils.
Airavat (Elephant) Ratna - Indra dev kept this gem with him. Its secret is that when the mind is away from evils then only the intellect will be pure. Will shine like light.
Kaustubh Mani Ratna - Bhagavan Vishnu wore this gem on his heart. Its secret is that when bad thoughts are removed from our mind, when the intellect becomes pure, then devotion starts in the mind.
Kalpavriksha Ratna - This gem was planted by the gods in heaven. This tree is also considered a wish fulfilling tree. The secret of this gem is that during the time of devotion or churning of the mind, all your desires should be kept away.
Apsara Rambha (celestial being) Ratna - This gem was with the deity. It is synonymous with lust and selfishness. Its secret is that we should not be greedy during devotion.
Goddess Lakshmi Ratna – Gods, sages and demons all wanted to keep this gem with them. But Lakshmi ji accepted to stay with Bhagavan Vishnu. Which means wealth goes to those who know how to work.
Varuni Devi Ratna – The meaning of Varuni is wine. This was accepted by the demons. Its secret is that the addict is suppressed by evil.
Chandrama Ratna – It was worn by Lord Shankar on his head. Its essence is that when our mind is free from all evils, then we feel at peace.
Parijat Vriksha Ratna – It was accepted by all the gods, because on touching it the tiredness used to go away. Its secret is that when there is peace in the mind, then the fatigue of the body also goes away.
Panchjanyam Shankh (conch) Ratna - Bhagavan Vishnu kept it with him. Its secret is that after getting rid of fatigue, the mind gets engrossed in devotion.
Dhanvantari deity and Amrit Kalash Ratna - In fact, in the end, the deity Dhanvantari appeared in the form of the thirteenth gem. He had a pot of nectar in his hand as the fourteenth gem. Lord Dhanvantari made all the deities consume nectar and got rid of the curse. Its secret is that when we get engrossed in devotion after removing the evils, then it is decided to get the blessings of God.
Panchajanyam was the name of HIS conch. During the churning of the ocean, one of the things that emerged from the ocean was the Panchajanyam conch. It had five finger like protrusions and hence the name. It was originally in the possession of the Daityas (demons).
Śrī Kṛṣņa and Sudama HIS childhood friend got training from their Guru Sandeepani Rishi. Śrī Kṛṣņa wanted to repay HIS Guru for the knowledge thus acquired. The Guru and Guru Ma had a son Punar Dutta who had died long back. They pined for their son. When Śrī Kṛṣņa insisted on giving Guru Dakhina, they knowing very well HE is Bhagavan HIMSELF, asked their son back . After some hesitation, Śrī Kṛṣņa went to the world of Daityas and freed Punar Dutta. HE also got the conch which HE gave to His guru. Sandeepani Rishi gladly accepted his son and returned the conch to HIM.
Arjuna had a conch named Devdutta which was given to him by Varun Dev.
Bhima had a conch named Poundram. During the exile of the Pandavas, Bhima was fed poison by the Kauravas who wanted to kill him. His body was then floated down a river. The river took Bhima to Naga loka where his grandfather (the king of Naga loka) extracted the poison and Bhima was given a potion which endowed him with the strength of a thousand horses. He was given the conch named Poundram by his grandfather. Hanuman ji had given a boon to Bhīma that whenever required his conch Pauņḍra would blow ferociously and the sound would terrify the opposing army.
Though Dhrishtadyumna was the commander-in-chief of the Pandavas; Bhagavan was their undeclared leader. Arjuna and Bhimsena blew their conches after Bhagavan blew HIS conch.
anantavijayaṃ(m) rājā, kuntīputro yudhiṣṭhiraḥ,
nakulaḥ(s) sahadevaśca, sughoṣamaṇipuṣpakau. 1.16
Nakula and Sahadeva are the sons of Madri but nevertheless considered as Kunti's sons. Nakula blew his conch named Sughosha and Sahadeva blew his conch named Manipushpakau.
kāśyaśca parameṣvāsaḥ(ś), śikhaṇḍī ca mahārathaḥ,
dhṛṣṭadyumno virāṭaśca, sātyakiścāparājitaḥ. 1.17
drupado draupadeyāśca, sarvaśaḥ(ph) pṛthivīpate,
saubhadraśca mahābāhuḥ(ś), śaṅkhāndadhmuḥ(ph) pṛthakpṛthak. 1.18
Enraged Pitamah went to Kashi and challenged Kashi Raj to war or surrender and proposed to hand over the three girls to take them to Hastinapur. King Shalva tried to stop Bhishma but Pitamah defeated him. Princess Amba and King Shalva were in love. It was decided between them that King Shalva would come in the Swayamvar and Amba would select him and marry him. When Pitamah Bhishma was going to Hastinapur with the three princesses, Princess Amba told him about her desire to marry king Shalva.
On hearing this, Pitamah Bhishma respectfully sent Princess Amba to King Shalva. But King Shalva did not accept her, because Swayamvar did not happen and he was defeated by Bhishma Pitamah in the war. According to the Kshatriya religion, now accepting the princess Amba would mean accepting the princess as an object of charity. Being a Kshatriya, it was against Dharma.
Now Princess Amba could neither marry the Prince of Hastinapur, nor King Shalva was ready to marry her, nor could she go to her father Kashi Naresh. Mourning and filled with anger, Amba ended her life. But before embracing death, she vowed putting all her virtues at stake, that she would be the reason for the death of grandsire Bhishma. In her next birth as an impotent Shikhandi, acquired proficiency in the art of weapons to fight with Bhishma Pitamah. Bhishma Pitamah regarded Shikhandi as a woman and hence he did not use weapons on her.
In the Mahabharata war, Arjuna killed grandfather Bhishma by positioning Shikhandi in front of him and slayed Pitamh Bhishma.
Satyaki was the commander of Narayani Sena and had never ever been defeated and was very dear to Arjuna- allso blew his conch.
sa ghoṣo dhārtarāṣṭrāṇāṃ(m), hṛdayāni vyadārayat,
nabhaśca pṛthivīṃ(ñ) caiva, tumulo vyanunādayan. 1.19
A point to be noted is that Sanjaya and Vidur leave no opportunity to denigrate the Kauravas and Dhṛtarāṣṭra. In this verse too Sanjaya refers to the Kauravas as unrighteous.
atha vyavasthitāndṛṣṭvā, dhārtarāṣṭrānkapidhvajaḥ,
pravṛtte śastrasaṃpāte, dhanurudyamya pāṇḍavaḥ. 1.20
Bhagavan here addressed Arjuna as Kapi Dhvaja. In the ancient times, at the time of war, the eminent warriors displayed different flags which became their identity. Arjuna's flag had the insignia of Hanuman ji. Hence was called Kapi Dhvaja.
Near Badrinath was Kuber's kingdom, in which was a kadli vana. The flowers and fruits of this forest were very special. During exile the Pandavas passed through this forest. On the way Draupadi got attracted to a strong fragrance. She went towards the source and found a beautiful Lotus. Ordinarily Lotus's do not have a strong fragrance so Draupadi understood that this was not an ordinary flower. She requested Bhima to get more of such flowers for her. Bhima went in search of them and sighted one. However, an old and an enormous monkey was sleeping on the way. He woke up the monkey and requested him to give way. The monkey said he was too old to move so Bhima could cross over or physically move him out of the way. Crossing over anyone is inauspicious so Bhima tried to move the monkey's tail. He in his ego tried to move the tail with his small finger but failed. When he could not move the tail with his hand and all his might, he understood that this was no ordinary monkey. Bhima apologised and requested the monkey to reveal his true identity.
This is when Hanumanji revealed that they both are sons of Vayu Dev and hence are brothers. When Hanumān ji asked Bhīma to ask for any Boon, Bhīma wanted him to grace the form of Hanumān ji when he crossed the ocean for Lanka. Hanumān ji did mention that he was now old and that form existed eons ago but Bhīma insisted. To please him, Hanumān ji transformed himself to that form.
hṛṣīkeśaṃ(n) tadā vākyam, idamāha mahīpate,
arjuna uvāca
senayorubhayormadhye, rathaṃ(m) sthāpaya me'cyuta. 1.21
yāvadetānnirīkṣe'haṃ(y̐), yoddhukāmānavasthitān,
kairmayā saha yoddhavyam, asminraṇasamudyame.1.22
Bhagavan knew that Arjuna harboured second thoughts for going to war. So finding the right time, he like a seasoned surgeon who knows the right time for surgery, deliberately takes the chariot where Bhīṣma and Dronacharya are arrayed. HE wanted Arjuna to get rid of his fears and participate in the war whole heartedly.
yotsyamānānavekṣe'haṃ(y̐), ya ete'tra samāgatāḥ,
dhārtarāṣṭrasya durbuddheḥ(r), yuddhe priyacikīrṣavaḥ.1.23
sañjaya uvāca
evamukto hṛṣīkeśo, guḍākeśena bhārata,
senayorubhayormadhye, sthāpayitvā rathottamam. 1.24
bhīṣmadroṇapramukhataḥ(s), sarveṣāṃ(ñ) ca mahīkṣitām,
uvāca pārtha paśyaitān, ṣamavetānkurūniti. 1.25
Being an excellent guide and counselor, Parameśvara knew that unless Arjuna faced his worst fears of fighting his dear ones, he would perhaps not fulfill his duties to his fullest capacity. Thus, HE positioned the Chariot in a way where both Bhīṣma and Droņācārya were visible to Arjuna knowing that he had a soft corner for them that might become his weakness in the middle of the war when facing them.
This was done on purpose; HIS Mysterious ways of guiding his friend, a greatest devout in the right direction.
One could now hear Hṛṣīkeśh (The one in control of HIS senses), asking Arjuna to face his worst fears; His dearest Grand Uncle Bhīṣma and beloved teacher Droņācārya.
Bhagavān called Arjuna as guḍākeśena. It has 2 meanings,
- One who has conquered sleep.
- The one with curly hair.
Arjuna wanted to obtain the divine weapons to perform his tapasya (Voluntary acceptance of austerity for the purpose of detaching oneself from the sense objects). Thus, mastery over sleep was important. He achieved this goal by performing tapasya on a branch of a tree hanging over a river. As and when he fell asleep out of sheer exhaustion; he would fall in the river, thus becoming fully alert, and with determination, and practicing religiously he with the passage of time gained control over his sleep.
Laksmana took charge of organising and arranging the structures for food and dwelling during their exile of 14 years (Ramayana). In the night, he would still stay awake with his bow primed, taking guard in a posture alert and ready to confront undesirable visitor. Such was his devotion to Bhagavān Ram and his desire to safeguard HIM and Mata Sita.
Thus, Arjuna was no ordinary warrior, he had undertaken various feats and was also dear to Bhagavān. Yet, while facing his dearest ones, he too was in a dilemma over his decision. And this, was noticed and deduced by Yogeśvara.
tatrāpaśyatsthitānpārthaḥ(ph), pitṝnatha pitāmahān,
ācāryānmātulānbhrātṝn, putrānpautrānsakhīṃstathā. 1.26
śvaśurānsuhṛdaścaiva, senayorubhayorapi,
tānsamīkṣya sa kaunteyaḥ(s), sarvānbandhūnavasthitān. 1.27
In the beginning Arjuna was enthusiastic to fight with the Kauravas. Like a true warrior he had asked Bhagavan to take the chariot to the centre of the two armies. Now standing amidst his own elders, relatives, friends and well wishers, he was deluded and thus the enthusiasm was replaced with sadness and despondency.
The session concluded with Hari Nam Sankirtan.
Question 1: Upendra ji
In the 15 chapter there is reference to 6 indriyas whereas we know of indriyas to be 5.
मन:षष्ठानीन्द्रियाणि प्रकृतिस्थानि कर्षति || 7||
Why all the Gods incarnated in India only
Answer : Bharat is the best land in the whole globe. The Himalayas, the Ganga are in Bharat. We have six seasons and a variety of topography with rivers, oceans, mountains etc. God choses the best for HIMSELF.
Question 3: Neha ji
What was the fate of Shikhandi and Shakuni
Answer: Shikhandi was killed in the war. Shakuni was killed by Nakul and Sahdev.